ARTICLES

BACK TO SPRIG HOME 

Sprig Magazine publishes two articles per month, written by our wonderful team of freelance writers. 


THE TEAM/WRITERS 

Email
Instagram
04

Yep. It's Another Thinkpiece about the Melbourne Arts Scene



Yep. It's Another Thinkpiece about the Melbourne Arts Scene


By Alexia Shaw 
they/she

Alexia Shaw is a Naarm-based writer and artist. Their work has been published in Farrago Magazine, Happy Mag and Judy's Punch, and their plays have been presented as part of MUDFest and Tastings Festival. Their interests include trivia nights, 2010s music, and liminal spaces.

instagram: @alexia_shaw_


Edited by Maximilian Levy associate editor
he/him
Maximilian Levy is a Melbourne/Naarm-based writer of short fiction and creative essays, a poet of questionable talent, and the founder, curator, and host of Folk ’N Words, a recurring poetry and folk music event based in Adelaide/Tarntyana. As an editor at Sprig Magazine, it brings him great joy to contribute to a publication that cultivates bold and meaningful articulation––written, curated, and read by patrons of literature and the arts, two of life's tremendous gifts.



I’m at Malthouse Theatre with a friend when my card declines. 


I’ve taken them to see Break of Day; a new play starring Kat Stewart. I’ve booked two healthcare card tickets for the discounted price of $55 a piece, but when we reach the counter my friend can’t find their card in their wallet. “I’ve got mine, is that enough?” I ask The Person Behind the Ticket Counter. They shake their head. “Sorry, I’ll have to charge you the extra $15 for a regular ticket.” 


The machine beeps sadly. A rejection. “Sorry, give me a second,” I say. I fumble around to transfer money to my spending account and tap again. Beep. The Person Behind the Ticket Counter hands me a pair of tickets. “Enjoy the show!” they say cheerily. 


We make it into the theatre and find the seats that set us back a combined $125. We settle in, and for the next two hours we watch as a woman and her daughter struggle to live below the poverty line. About halfway through, I take a moment to look around the room, which seems to be largely filled with well-dressed retirees and Gen Xers donning designer statement glasses. I look back to the stage, where Australian success story Kat Stewart is mid-monologue, reflecting on the injustice of living paycheck-to-paycheck in an exaggeratedly broad accent. I want to believe it, but all I can think about is how her Wikipedia page says she spent part of her childhood travelling around Europe, and that she’s famous enough to be featured on Australian Who Do You Think You Are?. Then I think about how if I had a nickel for every time I’ve paid over $50 for a ticket to see an anti-capitalist performance starring a household name actress, I’d have almost enough money to pay for another of those tickets (honourable mention to Euphoria at RISING Festival a few years ago, which featured Cate Blanchett quoting The Communist Manifesto). When the show concludes the crowd around us rumbles and raves to each other, but my friend and I say nothing. We give each other a look. I can tell they’re thinking the same thing I am: Did we really just pay $125 to watch poverty porn?


Don’t get me wrong, it’s great that stories about people on the fringes are being represented on stage. But it’s hard to find them authentic when, in reality, the people they’re about aren’t anywhere to be found. They’re not in the audience when tickets are $70 a pop, and they’re certainly not Kat Stewart, who’s been dressed in slouchy clothes and hoop earrings the size of Jupiter––an outfit that comes across as a caricature of a financially encumbered woman. The show feels like a conversation occurring entirely amongst the upper-middle class––a novelty piece, like an explorer writing home about the curious things they’ve encountered in their trips through far off lands. Because, let’s be honest, the characters in this show can’t enter this room as an audience member, and they’re even less likely to access it via the stage door as a creative.


But this is, of course, not a problem isolated to Malthouse, or even to theatre for that matter. It’s a broader issue in Melbourne’s arts scene that’s emerged on account of gatekeeping and sub-par accessibility that has impacted young artists in particular. For a city that prides itself on its arts and culture, we’re investing less and less into its longevity. In order to make good art, creatives need to engage with good art––but how can we expect young people to enjoy that opportunity when even an Under-30s ticket to a Melbourne Theatre Company show will set you back $50 (equivalent to roughly an hour and a half of minimum wage)? 


Not only are we being priced out of consuming art; we’re getting locked out of creating it too. Pathways and funding are drying up at an alarming rate, making the surviving opportunities increasingly competitive––every rejection email I’ve received this year has included the words “an unprecedented amount of applications.” Emerging artists are now having to compete with established ones, a condition exemplified by the Midsumma Queer Playwriting Award, which claims to be a development program that “aims to identify, support and develop new playwriting talent.” In 2024 this award went to Tom Ballard, a well-known stand-up comic with almost two decades of industry experience under his belt. How can any truly emerging talent catch a break without connections or a portfolio behind them? The catch-22 that all high schoolers applying for retail jobs know all too well has finally reached the arts industry: in order to gain experience, you need to have it already.


Gen Z is often told that we’re too sensitive, too woke. But it can’t be denied that as creatives we’ve been given the short end of the stick. The AI boom is killing career opportunities for writers; the recent rise in cost of living means picking up even more shifts at our day jobs just to cover rent; and to top it all off, we’re fighting ex-ABC TV hosts for development programs. So how do we vent our frustration towards this capitalist hellscape? We make more art, of course. Only, most people won’t actually see it.


Every generation has their own thing. In 1977, Helen Garner published Monkey Grip, an abrasive novel profiling young Melbournian bohemians and their troubled lives. Upon release the book met mixed reviews, but it was ultimately recognised as a foundational text of what some describe as “grunge lit”––an Australian literary movement highlighting the experiences of discontented young adults. Grunge lit was counter-culture art made by Gen X youths, stylistically opposed to anything made by previous generations. It was graphic, it was dirty, it was loud. It was their way of expressing the struggles they faced in a time of uncertainty; because, let’s face it, young people are always struggling in a time of uncertainty.  What changes is the way we express ourselves. 


Just like Gen X and all the generations before us, we’ve developed our own method of coping with adversity. In contrast to the bleakness of grunge lit, today’s youth are using humour and brightness to broadcast our grievances. Our pessimism concerning the future has transcended  anger and arrived at resignation. Yes: the world has gone to shit. No: we can’t do much about it. When everything is so terribly dire, it ceases to be tragic, and becomes hilariously silly instead. So we manifest this in our art, embracing absurdism and maximalist aesthetics. Talk nonsense! Cover everything in rhinestones, just because! Who cares!––None of it is going to be here much longer anyway. The combination of Melbourne’s lingering grunge aesthetic with Gen Z’s ability to derive humour from futility is producing art that is bizarre, funny, thought-provoking, and emotionally stirring all at once. 


The problem is: no one beyond our demographic is taking notice. Sure, there’s some fabulous independent venues willing to give us a fighting chance (The Motley and La Mama, for instance, have been championing emerging artists for years), but that’s simply not enough. We need larger institutions platforming emerging voices, taking risks on artists without  flourishing  portfolios and impressive industry networks behind them. It seems Gen X has forgotten the rebellious spirit of their youth, and have instead become content to occupy their echo chambers like the generations before them––regurgitating identical perspectives back-and-forth because no one new is allowed to step up to the plate. They refuse to give us access to the same creative opportunities they fought for decades ago. But if we keep platforming the same established voices over and over again, we will miss this exciting new generation of artists entirely, and the stagnation of Melbourne’s art scene will only get worse. It will become increasingly homogenous; a dangerous thing when the surge of conservative politics is already pushing assimilation under the guise of unity. 


It’s the end of winter and I’m at a house party in Thornbury, celebrating the life of a legacy share house before its imminent demolition; a story that’s becoming all too common. The room is dark; the wallpaper is peeling; the small lights set up in the corner are a vibrant shade of purple. Spillway, a local musical duo, perform songs about perfection and humanity and Yarra trams on an acoustic guitar and a violin. Their music is brash and their lyrics are absurd. The audience watches, transfixed; and it makes me sad to think that they might never get the chance to play to a crowd bigger than this. And it’s not because they’re untalented––in fact, they’re a fantastic representation of everything great about Gen Z’s emerging artistic style in Melbourne. But that’s exactly why they’ll struggle to get a platform. 


While it’s true that, often, the best art is recognised for its brilliance only in hindsight, this doesn’t always have to be the case. We could start supporting young artists and their work now, while it’s relevant, and breathe some new life into an arts scene that feels increasingly dated. Yes, the hefty ticket prices are a big deterrent for young people’s arts engagement; but I also know that most people my age are nonetheless willing to save up and shell out for concert tickets time and again. As such, it must be said that it’s not only the cost that’s keeping them away; it’s also the content, with so much of professional theatre and festival programming lacking material made by or for the young people of Melbourne. But that could be fixed, if the industry was only willing to take the plunge. Taking risks on young talent, offering pricing schemes that correspond to the rise in living costs, and funding more development programs are all crucial steps towards creating more genuinely accessible pathways that don’t require having the words “Victorian College of the Arts” on your resume. The arts have always been a place for discourse; but we can’t have effective discourse if we’re leaving all of our young people out of the conversation. As AI booms, literacy rates plummet, and conservatism looms, we need more than ever for both established artists and those of the next generation to be asking questions and encouraging original thought. The arts cannot be sustained by the voices of just one insular community. There is a rich vein of untapped talent in this city; we shouldn’t let it stay underground.






SPRIG MAGAZINE 2026